I've had the latest Rolling Stone article about Afghanistan on my "To Read" pile for a few days. Before I could get to it, however, I got distracted by the flurry of posts about the article.
The author, Nir Rosen, traveled with Taliban fighters to a meeting with a Taliban commander. While Rosen doesn't actually witness the Taliban fighting US, Afghan, or NATO troops, he very well could have--and in fact, set out with the intent of observing a Taliban attack, if the opportunity presented itself:
They have promised to take me to see the Taliban in
action: going out on patrols, conducting attacks, adjudicating
disputes and providing security against bandits and police.
Some bloggers, including Bing West, took exception with what Rosen did--loud, angry exception. And I largely agree with them.
During war, public information about the other side is critical. Citizens cannot judge the wisdom or stupidity of the war without knowing something about the adversary. Whether the reality of the enemy is better or worse than the caricature that emerges out of ignoramce, the important thing is, the caricature is wrong. It does not tell you what it's really going to take to defeat the adversary. Debates over the war then inevitably collapse into disagreements over the military actions we pursue, with practically no reference to the people who are their target, or the effect these operations have. Ultimately, this kind of one-sided discussion is not really about war at all, but some kind of fictional military engineering problem.
In fewer words, then, it's just important to recognize the importance of getting information about our adversaries. There's no question that, not only is that an important service that journalists can provide, but it's arguably their duty.
The real question, though, is how they go about that task. Interviewing a Taliban commander isn't wrong. Agreeing to accompany Taliban fighters during a mission to kill Afghan or Western soldiers is.
Instead of spilling a lot of my own words about this topic, I urge you to watch the second part of the "Under Orders, Under Fire" episode of Ethics In America. Both this series and The Constitution: A Delicate Balance were filmed in the 1980s. Prepare to be surprised by whom you'll see in these excellent discussions, what they say, and how well they say it.
After starting "Under Orders, Under Fire," you should first listen to the brief but illuminating discussion about torture in war. Then go to the second part, in which the panel wrestles with the problem of an American journalist traveling with enemy soldiers, just as Rosen did. The real kicker comes when a Marine colonel makes the rhetorical question: what happens when American soldiers are in a position to save endangered journalist?
If that doesn't paint a clear enough picture for you, watch this short video of a British journalist and British soldiers caught in a Taliban ambush. Next, imagine yourself as a journalist on the other side of this firefight. If you didn't have doubts whether you should be there...Well, you're a cold-hearted bastard, at the very least.
Bing West goes a little farther than necessary to make his point. Comparing the Taliban (whom I am not defending) to the Waffen SS just gives critics the opportunity to give less weight to the important part of his argument. You don't need "American moral lassitude" to explain one journalist who displayed faulty judgment.
I strongly recommend reading Robert Farley's analysis, which makes many excellent points that I don't need to repeat here. However, I'll make one last observation of my own. Rosen's article just isn't very good. He leaps to broad conclusions about the Taliban from encounters with a small group of them. Not only does that leave him open to the compound fallacy, but it's not impossible to imagine that some of the softer, nicer elements of Taliban life were staged for his benefit.
Even if you take everything he sees at face value, the narrative of the story is, "My wild, dangerous trip to see an ornery Taliban commander." His experience may add to our understanding of the war in Afghanistan, but it's too small for the general conclusions about the war that Rosen wants to make.
Rosen was most likely more a burden than an asset for the Taleban during that time - I wouldn't attribute any advantages for the Taleban except propaganda (which is the same case as with an interview).
I have a feeling that you draw the line based on emotion, not based on help/no help.
You began rational, but then you took a turn to pretty much 'I don't like that!'
And then there's another interesting question: What if Rosen was a South African who happened to write for the magazine? Would that have changed anything? If yes - why?
Posted by: Sven Ortmann | 10/31/2008 at 04:35
Interesting perspective, but the important word here seems to be "American", not "journalist". Non-American/British journalists do not seem to exist, for example, and the moral obligations of American/British journalists in wars that don't include American/British soldiers are left unclear.
Posted by: Charrua | 11/03/2008 at 08:59
This posting presents an interesting perspective no doubt. I believe that the war journalists do have some moral obligations.
Posted by: DHB | 05/21/2009 at 12:21
On the other hand, everything in the UGGS Boots on sale collection runs large and stretches with each wear. For the UGGS Boots Collection (which has such items as the Ugg Classic Cardy Boots, UGG Australia Boots, and UGGS Boots on sale4) UGG 5815 recommends that you size down a full size. If you’re a half size, hold on to your hat: while UGG boots recommends sizing down a half size if you are between sizes (a size 8.5 would then get an 8)u2200wwx
Posted by: UGG Australia Boots | 10/04/2010 at 18:58
The tweeter that fails to tweet is also the tweeter that fails to gain followers and influence.
Posted by: web design | 04/20/2011 at 00:02
Nice pic! Good light! It's very inspiring for me.
Posted by: Oakley Sunglasses UK | 06/08/2011 at 19:07
This looks absolutely perfect. All these tinny details are made with lot of background knowledge. I like it a lot. This was a useful post and I think it is rather easy to see from the other comments as well that this post is well written and useful.
Posted by: ralph lauren outlet | 07/13/2011 at 22:50
This was a useful post and I think it is rather easy to see from the other comments as well that this post is well written and useful.
Posted by: oakley frogskins | 07/20/2011 at 01:30
Not only an excellent way to promote a new business, but a reliable way to increase sales. In this economy, this is definately a way to sustain your growth. Who doesn't need more clients? Give it away if you can, and keep traffic coming in!
Posted by: Global UGGs | 08/10/2011 at 18:42
good articles sir... your blog is very helpful... I am happy to find this post very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. I always prefer to read the quality content and this thing I found in you post. Thanks for sharing.
Marketing Dissertation Topics
Posted by: Dissertation | 09/12/2011 at 08:33
This was a useful post and I think it is rather easy to see from the other comments as well that this post is well written and useful.
Posted by: burberry scarf sale | 11/29/2011 at 23:10
This article is GREAT it can be EXCELLENT JOB and what a great tool!
Posted by: Microsoft Office | 12/06/2011 at 20:20
This is all very new to me and this article really opened my eyes. Thanks for sharing with us your wisdom.
Posted by: beats by dre it | 03/23/2012 at 23:49
This is all very new to me and this article really opened my eyes. Thanks for sharing with us your wisdom.
Posted by: beats by dre it | 03/23/2012 at 23:51
You will discover a positive count of 2 or more, it's vert light for you to go ahead and place higher craps bets. If unquestionably the bonuses cancel the possibility of cashing out, then it would really be of the case use for serious online gamers who want to spend their earnings. ipad covers iphone 5 cases cheap iphone 4 cases (http://Grizzlygadgets.com) cute iphone 5 cases (grizzlygadgets.com) samsung galaxy s2 case (grizzlygadgets.com) iphone 5 Cover best ipad 3 cases ipad keyboards custom iphone case ipad cover cool iphone 4 case samsung s3 case ipad keyboard case iphone 4 Cases iphone 5 bumper case (grizzlygadgets.com) iphone 4 leather case (grizzlygadgets.com) best Ipad Case iphone 4 aluminum case (http://grizzlygadgets.com) ipad Charger ipad charger ipad Case with keyboard Iphone 4S Case iphone 4s cases (http://grizzlygadgets.com/iphone-accessory) phone cases for samsung galaxy s2 (grizzlygadgets.com) samsung galaxy s2 cases (grizzlygadgets.com) cases for ipad 3 ipad bluetooth keyboard; grizzlygadgets.com, apple ipad 2 case (grizzlygadgets.com) best case for Samsung galaxy s3 leather case for iphone 5 ipad 2 case iphone 4 battery [http://grizzlygadgets.com] best galaxy s3 accessories (http://grizzlygadgets.com) kate spade iphone 4 case Ipad mini keyboard Cases For Iphone 4 iphone 5 charger - http://grizzlygadgets.Com/, best iphone 4s case best ipad mini cases Ipad 2 leather case cool iphone 5 cases kate spade iphone 4 case Iphone 4 cases iphone aluminum case, grizzlygadgets.com, leather iphone 4 case zagg ipad Keyboard iphone 4 accessories iphone accessories (grizzlygadgets.com) galaxy s3 case otterbox iphone 4 cases; grizzlygadgets.com, best iphone 5 case samsung galaxy s3 cases amazon best ipad 3 cases (grizzlygadgets.com) best case for ipad 3 (http://grizzlygadgets.Com/new-ipad-3-cases) best case for iphone 4s phone cases for iphone 4 (Grizzlygadgets.com) iphone 5 cases samsung galaxy s2 case aluminum iphone case ipad keyboard case samsung galaxy s2 cases (http://grizzlygadgets.com) iphone aluminum case iphone 4s case ipad mini smart cover [grizzlygadgets.com] waterproof iphone 4 case aluminum iphone 4 case ipad mini case samsung galaxy s2 cases ipad 2 covers and cases Iphone 5 Headphones - Grizzlygadgets.Com - best ipad 3 cases (http://grizzlygadgets.com) iphone 4s cases iphone 4 case covers for ipad 3 Iphone 5 battery case (grizzlygadgets.com) waterproof iphone case metal iphone 5 Case best iphone 4 case iphone 5 aluminum case keyboard for ipad 3 accessories for samsung galaxy s3 (http://grizzlygadgets.com/accessories-for-samsung-galaxy) Best iphone 4S cases iphone 4 cases ipad covers ipad 2 covers and cases samsung galaxy s3 cases (http://grizzlygadgets.com/) apple ipad case ipad 3 cases and covers galaxy s3 charging case [http://grizzlygadgets.com/] iphone 5 wallet case Iphone 4 Cases best case for ipad 2 best ipad mini case s3 case waterproof iphone Case iphone leather case cool iphone 4s cases iphone 4s leather case ipad case - grizzlygadgets.com, ipad case [http://grizzlygadgets.com/apple-ipad-cases] best iphone 5 case ipad 3 Cases iphone 4 battery ipad 4 cases iphone 5 cases iphone cases best ipad mini case
Posted by: ipad covers | 10/02/2013 at 08:54