My Photo

Core topic

« The moral imperatives of war journalism | Main | Happy Halloween from manservant Hecubus »




Short answer: Press coverage of the other side is essential. Being in a situation where you might be complicit in the killing of Americans is not defensible.

Just on this point, what would you think if the journalist had not been a US citizen, but from a country that was not taking part in the war in Afghanistan. Would you think it unethical for a US media organ to carry the reporting of such a journalist?


"At the level of the Secretary of Defense and the JCS Chairman, there has not been a clear strategy for Afghanistan. Gates is reactive. The strategic review should have happened a long time ago."

I think that this is a big blind spot of West and probably others. The point is not that OSD or the JCS should have done a strategic review of how things are going in Afghanistan. They KNOW that it's going nowhere, but they have no options if the White House refuses to allow them any options. I would suggest that it is the failure at the higher levels - the White House and NSC - that has limited the OSD/JCS staff from supporting any position other than "stay the course, Iraq is the focus."

Of course, it's easier for Bing and others to criticize the military than the Bush/Cheney team. It allows them to retain their conservative credentials if they don't criticize the political leadership that ought to be developing strategic policy that is executable and moves us forward in a positive direction.


Nice post, but expressions like "moral clarity", "moral lassitude", "agnosticism", "the righteousness of our cause", etc. definitely make it look like West has a moral/religious view of the Irak/Afghanistan wars and views what he perceives as the lack of enthusiasm of Gates for said wars as a kind of moral failure. I can't see his writings as an even-handed take on the strategic failures of the Pentagon, but more like the lament of a zealot that argues that the Pentagon doesn't like killing foreigners ENOUGH.


This is a rather interesting posting no doubt. It makes a good read. I guess that the Iraq/Afghanistan wars have brought forth the western world’s view on the matter.

UGG 5815

On the other hand, everything in the UGGS Boots on sale collection runs large and stretches with each wear. For the UGGS Boots Collection (which has such items as the Ugg Classic Cardy Boots, UGG Australia Boots, and UGGS Boots on sale4) UGG 5815 recommends that you size down a full size. If you’re a half size, hold on to your hat: while UGG boots recommends sizing down a half size if you are between sizes (a size 8.5 would then get an 8)u2200wwx


This could be keeping your doors and windows locked at all times and also taking care that any and every entrance is secured against unauthorized entry.

Oakley Sunglasses UK

Nice pic! Good light! It's very inspiring for me.

Global UGGs

Not only an excellent way to promote a new business, but a reliable way to increase sales. In this economy, this is definately a way to sustain your growth. Who doesn't need more clients? Give it away if you can, and keep traffic coming in!

Cheap Oakley Sunglasses

This is my early farm blinddays. I gave him

Microsoft Office

This article is GREAT it can be EXCELLENT JOB and what a great tool!

The comments to this entry are closed.