The Leninist strategy

THEORY
Mao distilled a strategy for waging revolutionary from the periphery of a society that, to be honest, borrowed many bits and pieces from generations of revolutionaries who preceded him. Mao's prominence as a revolutionary thinker owes a great deal to how vividly and compellingly he pulled the old and new pieces into a direct, muscular, and credible formula for toppling an ancient regime. While other revolutionary movements had leaders who spoke eloquently about what to do after the seizure of power, almost none of them have the clarity and simplicity of Mao's works on how to make the old regime collapse. One of the strongest candidates is Lenin, so an important strain of revolutionary doctrine is fairly called Leninist.

Before getting into the details of the "Leninist" strategy, it's important to note how I'm using the term. Not all "Leninists" in the broad way I'm using the term are Marxists. Many Leninist groups, including some contemporary Islamic revolutionaries, despise Marxism. However, these groups would like to re-create an iconic revolutionary moment, Lenin's arrival at the Finland Station in St. Petersburg, in their own terms.

The Leninist approach attacks the centers of power directly. Where Maoists fight a war rooted in the countryside, Leninists wage their struggle in the cities—often, the capital.  In this respect, theorists of revolution mirror the differences among theorists of conventional warfare. Where some, like Basil Liddell-Hart, advocate the "indirect approach," probing the enemy's weaker areas and circumventing the tough defenses surrounding the most valuable objectives, others argue for a direct assault on the enemy's "center of gravity." Strategic surprise is important, as are any other methods (mass attack, attrition, etc.) that can crack open or wear down the defenses around these vital objectives. For example, Grant finally succeeded where his predecessors as commander of the Army of the Potomac failed because he was willing to grab Lee's Army of Northern Virginia by the throat and not let go. He was willing to take horrendous casualties at the battles of the Wilderness, Spotsylvania, and Cold Harbor that might have led other Union generals to resign. Grant held on, attacking hammering at the Confederate Army until it could no longer defend the Confederacy. This strategy had nothing of the indirect approach in it. Similarly, the Bolsheviks and Mensheviks in the Russian Revolution carried out a sustained political assault against the Tsar's autocracy, and then later, the short-lived coalition governments. They didn't always fight in the open, manning the barricades or leading mass demonstrations. However, unlike the Maoist strategy of slowly bleeding the regime's lifeblood away through a thousand tiny cuts, the Russian revolutionaries went straight for the jugular.

As I wrote earlier, many revolutionary organizations try to ride a general crest of dissatisfaction with the old regime. The Bolsheviks, Jacobins, Sandinistas, and Iranian Islamists all succeeded this way. The broadly-felt outrage against the regime lead to its collapse; in the confusion afterwards, the disciplined, organized, and motivated radicals seize power. In short, Leninist-style revolutionaries depend on alliances with other groups to topple the regime, and then happily turn on their former allies. Where Maoists see the revolution triumph with a final, massive assault on the regime, the Leninists see the moment of triumph as a putsch.

This pattern might explain why the writings of many "Leninists" often emphasize revolutionary consolidation. Where Maoists assume they have already won the allegiance of a broad segment of the population, the Leninist revolutionary vanguard cannot.

In other words, the theater and operational levels of strategy look very different between Maoist and Leninist approaches. The tactical and technical methods, however, may be very much the same. Organizing secret revolutionary cells, publishing propaganda, assassinating government leaders, and building political alliances through front organizations, are all tactical measures that Maoists and Leninists share. The higher levels of strategy that these tactical methods serve look very different.

During the 1960s, the doctrinal debates among Maoists and Leninists led to the creation of a term, urban guerrilla, that has created confusion ever since. The problem isn't figuring out the distinction between Maoist and Leninist strategies, which could not be more obvious. The confusion arose because of a matter of timing with a parallel historical development, the literally explosive emergence of terrorist groups in the Middle East and Europe. Were the Tupemaros in Uruguay and the Black September terrorists who slaughtered the Israeli Olympic team both urban guerrillas. In other words, were all urban guerrillas just terrorists by another name? For many in the thick of these tumultuous and frightening events, the answer was, Yes, of course. In hindsight, I think the answer should be, Clearly not.

Assassination, kidnapping, and sabotage are tactical methods shared by terrorists and urban guerrillas. The critical difference—again, driven by the operational, theater, and grand strategic levels—is the choice of targets. Urban guerrilla warfare uses these methods against the regime. Anyone who is a government official, police officer, or uniformed member of the armed forces is a fair target. Innocent bystanders are not.

People who adopt terrorist methods, deliberately attacking the population, have a distinct revolutionary strategy in mind. By necessity, they also have a completely different justification for their revolutionary methods than Leninist urban guerrillas. Holding airline passengers hostage, detonating bombs in train stations, spraying diners at a restaurant with automatic weapons fire—in the minds of terrorist strategists, these are practically necessary to meet their revolutionary objectives. The terrorist theorists believe attacks on the most innocent will trigger a chain of events that will lead more quickly and effectively to victory than scrupulously limiting the target list to representatives of the enemy government. Urban guerrillas, by and large, have rejected these methods as morally repugnant, or just practically counter-productive.

It's worth remembering here the critical distinction between terrorist groups and terrorist methods. We call Al Qaeda a terrorist organization because of its reliance on terrorist methods. However, other groups less clearly definable as "terrorists" occasionally attack innocent bystanders. For example, the National Liberation Front started its revolutionary struggle against the South Vietnamese government by assassinating police, military, and civilian officials. The regular killing of village and district chiefs was a trademark tactic of the NLF. However, the NLF also shelled villages with mortars and rockets, clearly a step over the line into terrorist methods. As I noted in earlier posts about revolutionary violence, revolutionary groups shift tactics. Except in the most obvious cases, the debates over which group deserves the terrorist label is usually pointless. At an academic level, there's no standard for how many terrorist attacks you have to commit before becoming a bona fide terrorist. At a practical level, we're trying to stop terrorist attacks altogether, regardless of who's executing them.

PRACTICE
Since this post is pretty long already, I won't weigh down the Practice section with too many words. This description of the Leninist revolutionary strategy is obviously applicable the Iraqi civil war and other contemporary conflicts. It should also be pretty obvious why I express constant frustration about how the American press and the US government depict the Iraqi insurgency, as if it were a single enemy with unified goals and methods. It is not. There is no "Iraqi insurgency." There are several groups, all of whom have seized the opportunity to fill a power vacuum with their own political ambitions. In other words…

• Not every attack on Iraqi police and military recruits is a terrorist attack.
• Not every group fighting the current Iraqi government would approve of suicide bombings that deliberately target civilians.
• Not every group that wants to compel the United States to withdraw from Iraq seeks a revolution in its aftermath.
• Not every alliance of different political factions is sustainable, if "Leninists" (in my broad meaning of the term) lurk within their ranks.

Comments

[Matthew Shugart]

Well done. I'm glad you linked it today, as I missed it back in July.

I think it is worth noting that "Leninist" may be used another way, too. Rather than referring to a specific tactic for overthrowing a regime (i.e. assaulting the center of power, rather than using an inside-out strategy), the term can also refer to a specific way of organizing.

In this sense, Leninist parties (or other organizations) are built on networks of "cells" that reduce the risk of the entire organization's being compromised if one cell is captured (before seizing power) and that facilitate the take-over of the military and bureuacratic organizations (afterwards, i.e. in the "consolidation" phase).

It also refers to the internal mechanism by which these organizations operate: democratic centralism. That is, encouraging (limited) debate to keep the organization somewhat flexible, but ensuring that ultimate decisions always rest with the center (and often a single charismatic leader). (As an aside, Ken Jowitt has referred to Leninist movements as being typified by the "charisma" being in the organization itself.)

All of the above could be developed further. The point is that "Leninist"--as I have tried to extend the term here--can refer to an organizational structure as well as to a set of tactics.

I think it is safe to say that the organizational structure is probably critical to the success of the revolutionary tactics you define as Leninist. But the structures are also useful for other purposes; i.e. control and middle-leadership circulation AFTER the seizure of power.

Some nominally democratic parties organize themselves in this cell-like fashion--notably the Accion Democratica which used to be the most important party in democratic Venezuela. (Chavez learned as much about creating revolutionary cells from AD as he did from Castro, given that the latter pretty much disdained the entire Leninist approach.)

[Matthew Shugart]

By the way, I definitely would not classify the FSLN's path to power as emblematic of "Leninist" tactics. In fact, as a tactic for seizing power, Leninism should be reserved for more specific tactics than an assault on the government's center of gravity. The FSLN did that, but in a pattern of far broader alliances with other (mostly middle-class) groups than, for example, Lenin himself.

Upon coming to power, on the other hand, the FSLN turned in a distinctly Leninist organizational direction. It remains such to this day.

[met]

The Ditch (Le Fosse), a film mbt shop exploring Chinese labor camps for dissidents, is a late addition to Venice Film Festival entries vying for the Golden Lion award.Directormbt shoes Wang Bing's entry is a documentary-like project set in the late 1950s, when China's communist government condemned to forced labor thousands of citizens who were considered dissidents for a variety of reasons.For the film discount mbt, the director said he interviewed many survivors of Jiabiangou Camp and "learned from them about the realities of their time there."The screenplay mbt

[ling]

The articulate beloved can buoy advert to an assortment by a different beliefsrolex watch , commonwealths, and positions running shox , arraying by general delight ("I enjoyed that repast") to acute social attracter ("I beloved blimey married woman")ed hardy jeans. "Beloved" can buoy as well advert specifically to the ablaze trust and affair by amatory beloved, to the love by eros (californium. Grecian actor's line as love), to the aroused familiarity by genetic beloved, or to the passionless beloved that delimitates friendly relationship , to the fundamental unity or cultism by spiritual beloved. on 17878996852005

[custom kicks online]

ns. You get to hear more than one point-of-view.

[newest jordan shoes]

I dont know what to say. This blog is fantastic. Thats not really a really huge statement, but its all I could come up with after reading this. You know so much about this subject.

[Nike Dunk Low]

I was shocked to see a structure as large, loud, overdone and bombastic as this put right smack on the Mall. That's sacred territory man. You can't just put any damn fool thing down there. And right in the middle of it all? Not off to the side like the rest of war memorials? The other memorials are small, intimate and remind you that this vast experience is barely understandable to us. Nike Dunk LowThat’s right; affordable options exist That creates some new consider kicks. Air Jordan Retro ShoesAnd generous ties go for a sweet money.Nike Sb Dunks 2010
Here is a tilt of upmarket dress mbt lami that won’t interrupt your dress shoes are a different gossip. I keep effective him to pause. mbt shoes sale are beautiful posh—children's Mbt shoes on sale shoes are $70 to $85." Custom Jordan Shoes you to hole the turn to get good-looking Mbt kaya .Higher prices for property made from juice products—including toys, Nike SB Dunk clothes, and mbt walking shoes —are having a collision. Nike SB Dunk High The Weis are steep, property shirts aren’t cheap, And with a little maintenance, these pieces.

[newest air jordans]

In the third, nike sneakers shop I think that Wesley Clark’s recent analysis of how America defeated the Soviet Union is on the mark,and that we will have to continue to push the contradictions on the various parties that are still entranced by the Marxist fallacies.retro jordan This requires engagement with Russia and the former Warsaw pact nations to keep Russia on track and to try to minimize backsliding in parts of the old SU. nike basketball shoes We need to work China off against North Korea, air jordan shop and we will at some point need to deal with Castro and his few remaining Western friends.

[Discount ugg boots]

In all likelihood,Women Timberlands the Germans could blow a Air Force

Ones hole through one or more sections of it, in which case Women

Parda shoes the French army would have Authentic Air Jordans to rush to plug these holes before the operationally nimble Wehrmacht could exploit them.

Since the Belgian gap was a hole that already existed in the Maginot Line Wide Women Shoes Kid Kicks.

[Natali Taylor]

Hello friends,this is a nice site and I wanted to post a note to let you know, good job! Thanks
Best regards, Natali, CEO of free music downloads

[rosetta stone]

I love your article. It can help me get much useful information. Hope to see more words in it. I think you will have interests to see
http://www.e-rosettastoner.com

[pinnacle security]

Several dead giveaways are always closing the drapes ONLY when you're not home.

[Panthers Cam Newton Jersey]

That is definately one of the best blogs I've sen in ages online. Maintain up the excellent posts.

[Jets Mark Sanchez Jersey]

Thanks so much for your work with the unborn! May you and your mission become abundanlty blessed, in Jesus name!

[Bears Devin Hester Jersey]

Very nice and helpful information has been given in this article. I must say that this is a very good post.

[best ipad keyboard case]

Then 150% entirely on their second deposit, and as a result 200% on their third deposit. Lion Slots Casino is powered simply Rival Gaming, which means this casino features i-Slots. I have a connected with some casino games which you might enjoy. best ipad keyboard case ipad Mini Cover case for iphone 5 Cases For Iphone 5 best case for galaxy s3 - grizzlygadgets.com - ipad stand unique iphone 4s cases best iphone 4s cases iphone 5 accessories best iphone case iphone 5 bumper case best ipad 4 cases ipad 2 leather case waterproof iphone 4 case; http://grizzlygadgets.com/, ipad 3 cases and covers galaxy s2 phone cases iphone 5 Accessories iphone 4 case (grizzlygadgets.Com) best Keyboard for Ipad metal iphone 5 case targus ipad 3 case iphone 4s case leather iphone 4 case ipad 3 cases aluminum iphone 4 case ipad 3 cases and covers ipad cases best (grizzlygadgets.com) ipad 3 cases with keyboard samsung s3 cases phone cases for galaxy s2; http://grizzlygadgets.com/samsung-galaxy-s2-case, cool iphone accessories waterproof iphone Case samsung s3 case iphone 4 charger best case for ipad 3 ipad mini keyboard case iphone 4s case iphone 5 Cases best iphone 5 cases ipad mini case cool iphone case cases for the samsung galaxy s3 phone cases for samsung galaxy s3 Ipad 3 Cover (Http://Grizzlygadgets.Com/New-Ipad-3-Cases) best case for iphone 5 Best Ipad mini cases ipad smart cover iphone 5 cases ipad covers (http://grizzlygadgets.com/ipad-accessories) speck iphone 4 case best ipad 4 cases (grizzlygadgets.com) Iphone 4 Charger cases for ipad 3 ipad mini covers iphone 5 accessories best Ipad mini case ipad 3 cases (Http://grizzlygadgets.Com/ipad-3-Accessory) ipad keyboard Ipad accessories (grizzlygadgets.com) accessories for samsung galaxy s3 custom iphone 5 cases Best iphone 4 Case best keyboard for ipad ipad accessories (grizzlygadgets.com) ipad accessories; grizzlygadgets.com, iphone 4s accessories ipad 3 cases with keyboard (http://grizzlygadgets.com) ipad cases with keyboard ipad mini cover accessories for galaxy S3 ipad 2 case review iphone 4 case (grizzlygadgets.com) Ipad 2 cases ipad mini covers case for galaxy s3 Iphone 5 aluminum case Cheap Iphone Cases galaxy s2 covers keyboard for ipad 3 iphone 4 cases (http://grizzlygadgets.com) best iphone 5 case custom galaxy s3 case ipad cases best custom ipad 3 cases Ipad 3 Accessories iphone 4 case (grizzlygadgets.com) Best Ipad 3 Case cases for iphone 5 [grizzlygadgets.com] coolest iphone cases iphone charger cases for Ipad 3 waterproof iphone case ipad 2 case iphone 4 case best ipad 3 cases cheap iphone 5 cases best iphone 4 case leather iphone case (grizzlygadgets.com) Ipad 4 Cases targus ipad 3 case case for samsung galaxy s2 (grizzlygadgets.com) ipad case with keyboard Iphone 4S Accessories cases for iphone 5 cases for ipad 3; http://grizzlygadgets.com/new-ipad-3-cases, ipad 3 Covers ipad 2 cases (Jessika)