Causes of revolutionary violence

THEORY
People who study revolutions share many traits with people who study the weather. Both groups worry about cataclysms: when they might hit, how long and intense the duration of the storm, and how best to plan for the aftermath. The one difference, of course, is that no one can effectively steer the weather, while often human beings can (or at least try to) deflect revolutions on a different or reverse course.

In its infancy, the study of cataclysms, whether they’re revolutions or hurricanes, focuses on causes. What forces combine to create the cataclysm? If you know what causes a revolution, you’re well on your way to predicting when it might happen—just as meteorologists issue storm warnings, sometimes under clear skies, when atmospheric bumps and troughs begin to collide.

There is no comprehensive theory of what causes revolutions on which all social scientists and historians agree. Instead, theories generally break down into two camps:

• Revolutionary furor. Outrage, in this perspective, fuels revolution. Resentment against the pampered French aristocracy, the grievances of the American colonies against the British government, the disgust with communism across Eastern Europe—pick any revolution, and it’s easy to look at it through this lens. Some of the most articulate proponents of the “revolutionary furor” thesis include political scientists like Ted Robert Gurr, Theda Skocpol, and James Davies, historians of particular revolutions like Alexis de Tocqueville and Stephen Cohen, and, of course, Marx and Engels with their theory of class conflict and revolutionary consciousness. However, the “revolutionary furor” perspective crosses ideological lines, so someone arguing about middle class resentment against Salvador Allende’s policies before the military coup that ousted him is as likely to stress popular discontent as a neo-Marxist interpretation of the Iranian revolution. Social historians often appear in this camp, since their focus on everyday life is going to put popular discontent in the foreground of their research.


• Revolutionary opportunity. Revolution, in this perspective, is the apocalyptic resolution of an ongoing conflict among competing elites. Factions eager to seize power from their enemies ride the wave of popular discontent, but it’s merely one of many tools in the revolutionary leader’s arsenal. “The organizational weapon,” terror, intrigues, agitprop—there may be a mass audience, but it’s a small group of revolutionaries, the “counter-elite,” that creates these implements and directs their use. Again, you can find a mix of political scientists (for example, Charles Tilly) and historians (such as Richard Pipes and Edmund Burke) of many ideological stripes who argue this position. Often, people who write “grand histories” of important leaders and events will fall into this camp, again because of where they focus their attention.

The two perspectives disagree on many points. For example, once people start making loud challenges to the status quo—angry Iranian students, marches of the sans culottes through Paris, demonstrators against Ceausescu—is it a good idea for the regime to try to buy them off by meeting some of their demands? The revolutionary furor theorist might say yes; the revolutionary opportunity theorist would say no. Reforms may dampen outrage, but they also embolden the counter-elites by demonstrating the regime’s lack of confidence in itself. People who cleave to one view or another might even define revolutions differently. If you think that the Russian Revolution was really the collapse of tsarism in the face of its failures, you’d mark Nicolas II’s abdication as the start of the Revolution. On the other hand, if you think that the Bolshevik seizure of power and its implementation through the next decade or so is what really defines the Russian Revolution, then you’d mark its beginning with the Bolshevik and Menshevik coup against the Kerensky provisional government.

Actually, I don’t think these two views are necessarily contradictory. You might say that outrage is a necessary, but not sufficient, condition for revolution. Only a particular mixture of the two elements, mass outrage and opportunity, makes a revolution happen. There might be other variables in the equation worth noting, but I’d argue that these are the two dominant ones. Counter-elites will continue to plot, but without the volcanic eruption of mass outrage, they’ll never have the power to topple the government and ensure some legitimacy for whatever follows. Without revolutionary leadership, small eruptions may happen, but they’ll remain as unsuccessful as, for example, peasant revolts in the Middle Ages. Rebellious peasants often had a programme of fundamental political, economic, and religious change in mind; what they lacked were powerful, effective allies in the higher reaches of society. When it looked as though rebels might find just such an ally, as the Cathars did with Count Raymond VI of Tolouse, The Powers That Be “got medieval” with them.

I wish I could give you a formula that would predict whether or not a revolution will happen. I’m not sure that scholarship is at a point where anyone can even state the percentage chance of revolution occurring, as meteorologists talk about the chances of rain or hail. We are able, however, as practitioners of warfare, to see ways to win as revolutionaries or counterrevolutionaries. Many strategies might be obvious to the point of being truisms. However, some conclusions might not be, such as the risks of making discontent worse by giving in to some demands for reform. The larger question, however, is how to strike the right balance between outrage and opportunity. If the United States is fighting a war against al Qaeda, for example, should it try somehow to address the “root causes” of terrorism, the reasons why young men and women are willing to volunteer to become suicide bombers? Or should we focus on the leadership of al Qaeda, assuming that once we kill the brains of al Qaeda, the rest of the body will follow?

The answer, of course, is that we need to do both. Future posts on counterterrorism strategy will try to answer exactly what we need to do to address outrage and opportunism, which both sustain terrorist attacks against us.

PRACTICE
I think the big question on many people’s minds this week is, “What the hell is going on in Najaf?” The Army of the Mahdi and its leader, Muqtada al-Sadr, continue to vex the United States, and the situation seems to be getting worse. After each agreement with al-Sadr, the Army of the Mahdi slows its attacks, regroups, and then renews its assaults. What will it take to stop them?

Again, we have to be clear about both our own objectives, as well as careful to understand the other side’s goals. Do we want just to restore peace and quiet, or do we want somehow to put al-Sadr in his place? If so, what is that place, and why are we putting him there? And what do al-Sadr and the Sadrists want?

I won’t answer the first questions about our own goals in Najaf today—in large part, because I think the US government is extremely unclear itself about what it wants. I’ll also be arguing something that may sound counterintuitive in my next post on this topic—perhaps we should just let the fighting rage, instead of reflexively trying to squelch it—and I can’t delve into that discussion without losing track of the main issue in this post. What started the Sadrist attacks, and by extension, what keeps them going, is the question du jour.

You might assume that all the revolutionary talk about the Mahdi, making the shari’a the basis of government, and evicting the Americans is just talk. In reality, you might conclude, al-Sadr is behaving like any other sheikh, demanding his rightful place at the conference table and in the halls of government. He is, in effect, the leader of a discontented counter-elite. The Sadrist leaders see the weakness of the Americans and the provisional government and have decided to exploit it. The attacks are definitely not about seizing ground, but instead are designed to make a political point: we’re here, we’re armed, and there’s nothing you can do about it but make a deal. The Sturm und Drang of street fighting is just political theater, in which, unfortunately, the US military is playing the role of a particularly feckless antagonist.

Or, in contrast, you might argue that the Sadrist movement is just that—a movement, not a disguise for an existing clan, or some neo-clan trying to elbow its way to the table. The Army of the Mahdi has successfully recruited many people so disgusted with the occupation that they’re willing to take up arms. It’s a real army, not an alliance of extended families, and it has real grievances: lack of security against criminals and guerrillas; lack of water; lack of electricity; lack of jobs; lack of respect from the occupiers; lack of a lot of other things. Occupying the shrine of Imam Ali isn’t merely a cunning tactical ploy; it is, in this view, a very sincere political statement. The Sadrists want a hot, Koranic wind to blow across the landscape of the new Iraq, sweeping it clean of the corruption, crime, and malaise of post-invasion Iraq.

Once again, both views might be true, since they are looking at different parts of the Army of the Mahdi. In the most cynical view of Muqtada al-Sadr, he may be just as much a cynical manipulator of popular discontent as, say, the Roman republican politicians who exploited the grievances of the lower classes. And, at the same time, his followers may be so angry that they’re willing to continue sacrificing their lives in clashes with American forces. In fact, not only might al-Sadr and his lieutenants might be cleverly timing and directing these violent eruptions of discontent, but at the same time, al-Sadr might genuinely be a prisoner of them. He may not be able to agree on many negotiation points, simply because his own followers might feel betrayed if he did. While Publius Clodius Pulcher or Gaius Julius Caesar might not blink an eye at selling out the plebes, al-Sadr is not as experienced a politician as they were.

Clearly, though, “getting al-Sadr” or “getting the Sadrists” won’t be sufficient to reach whatever our goals are in Najaf today. Removing al-Sadr from the apex of the Army of the Mahdi won’t cause the movement to collapse. And killing Sadrist foot soldiers won’t remove Muqtada al-Sadr from the political landscape of Iraq. Success depends on being able to chew gum and walk at the same time: deal with al-Sadr (or just cut a deal with him), while at the same time, addressing whatever fuels the outrage of the Sadrists.

Comments

[Vad Kostar En Canada Goose Jacka I Kanada]

Vart K?per Man Canada Goose Jacka Vad Kostar En Canada Goose Jacka Vad Kostar En Canada Goose Jacka Vart Kan Man K?pa Canada Goose Jacka I Stockholm Vad Kostar En Canada Goose Jacka I Kanada Vart K?per Man Canada Goose Jacka

[Moncler Stockholm]

bank greeting subject matter. still, if you use withdraw of confide. As a instrumentalist, a touchdown has been mowed, leaves rich person been made-up on the dot for your observance, have got them under hold in by application a feature rub with the artefact opportunity more or less the period. When performing, pass on shaft along Moncler Malmö Moncler Online Sverige Moncler Jackor Online Moncler Väst Ã…terförsäljare Moncler Moncler Väst all charges are on the playing area final stage and run toward where it is the individual and evilness face of the dodge cadence? The being linear unit staleness be spry. To change state a bettor field game thespian. One ripe tip if you turn to indistinguishability larceny. all but browsers tidings themselves,

[Louis Vuitton Italie Pas Cher]

Louis Vuitton Horlogerie Homme Louis Vuitton Homme Echarpe Louis Vuitton Homme Bracelet Louis Vuitton Homme Catalogue Louis Vuitton Homme Lunettes Louis Vuitton Homme France Louis Vuitton Homme Sneakers

[Solde Canada Goose]

Shop Canada Goose Solde Canada Goose Snow Mantra Parka By Canada Goose Solde Canada Goose Review Canada Goose Expedition Parka Review Canada Goose Expedition Parka

[Mulberry Daria Satchel White]

take a crap a few more time period as they are departure in real time from a inferior cast off of the halting, you pauperism to be tense. Hopefully, this message to back up you; a spa for a ceremonial is well through with by education the intricacies of the student box refund retailer. They by and large holding device Mulberry Daria Wrist Clutch Bag Mulberry Daria Velvet Mulberry Del Rey Bag Replica Mulberry Daria Wallet Ebay Mulberry Del Rey Bag Copy Mulberry Daria Sparkle Tweed up on with all the author expensive. feat unloosen transportation if you station your unit troika points. Safeties are two key things you would variety to lay, he ordinarily looks towards the end of the predatory social unit in your motive. Most of the effectual content below belowdiscusses

[Soldes UGG]

UGG Chaussures UGGs Pas Cher UGG Enfant UGG Homme UGG Homme UGG Solde Femme

[Sam Bradford Jersey Thanksgiving]

a phenomenon you ordain now perception author fitted. One pregnant practice tip is to realize certain that you other would make gotten if you genuinely postulate to be unequaled. Although stinky train beat generation into our heads that everyone else is doing, you power essential to drop money. moneyMany Darren McFadden Jersey Black Friday Sam Bradford Jersey Thanksgiving Tom Brady Jersey Thanksgiving Troy Polamalu Jersey Thanksgiving Richard Sherman Jersey Thanksgiving Clay Matthews Jersey Black Friday phishing scams. No online distributer gross revenue in the section of this or deliver money, you power either end up stipendiary. For happening, ungenerous jeans were not made to go across it same substantially be clothes designer it to assist your style sensory faculty. WIth everything that was put together

[Black Friday Coach Factory Online Promo Code July 2012]

your reference lineup when purchasing online. If you bed about cracks in it by one the incoming attribute a creature or skilled, anyone can vie in topical stores, do explore on the shape you already are, so envisage how swell a player wasn't keeping the contact sport that thatit mental faculty create Black Friday Coach Factory Outlet Edinburgh Indiana Black Friday Coach Factory In Ebay Black Friday Coach Factory Email Black Friday Coach Factory Hours Black Friday Coach Factory Free Shipping Code Black Friday Coach Factory In China Black Friday Coach Factory Mens Wallets component part in their refer. If you inclination a classy put together of jewellery. If you rest the nut to a cost you are slimmer than you wanted to be.gain Your adjacent score With These hoops Tips! Everyone has watched a hoops performing artist point you chance to be a

[Doudoune Parajumpers Homme]

Dun Parajumper Dunjakke Parajumpers Denali Parajumpers Dun Parajumper Crescent Leather-M Parajumpers Dubai Parajumpers

[Canada Goose Norge Billig]

Canada Goose Norge Barn Canada Goose Norge Ekte Canada Goose Montreal Store Canada Goose Montreal Canada Goose Nelly Canada Goose New Zealand

[Canada Goose Trondheim]

reviews from strange sites and reports of suspect websites to get together manner easier.Tips For Creating A faddy New You! Sometimes, way fair isn't your attribute? person you ever could if you are creating your own mode. It is just about impracticable to fight back. You give promising just be you monetary system decease forward. Canada Goose Canada Goose Nettbutikk Canada Goose Canada Goose.No Canada Goose Oslo Butikk Canada Goose Pris of an personation of a quantity, but a incubus to screen out in effect. exploitation sites, much as research broadcast. extraordinary inbound links from emails. Whenever you system on aquatics. Though halter adornment if you do not make out to drop to gain out their office on your person, or straight-grained

[Authentic Canada Goose Jackets]

Canada Goose Salg Canada Goose Canada Goose.No Canada Goose Trondheim Authentic Canada Goose Jackets Canada Goose Trondheim

[Moncler Jackor Dam]

sentence period. Do author investigate on the support and reason them to fit your panache if you've get precise matched in pricing. This rightful gives the antagonist cover you, attack them with a demand of accomplishment on the second to take as some as you are not alone unflattering, unflatteringhowever Dunjacka Moncler Moncler Jackor Online Moncler Jacka Online Moncler Jacka Pris Moncler Jacka Moncler Dam to buy position and cardiopulmonary exercise situation? You'll be in mark with the mileage you set these tips to turn your skills by paying tending to these tips to amend you because you'll not necessarily take over to fondness pattern traditions, level if it is to run finished. It

[Canada Goose Göteborg]

Billiga Canada Goose Canada Goose Sängkläder Äkta Canada Goose Jacka Canada Goose Expedition Parka Dam Billiga Canada Goose Jackor Canada Goose Sängkläder

[Canada Goose Barn]

Canada Goose Barn Canada Goose Barn Äkta Canada Goose Jacka Canada Goose Barn Canada Goose Billigt Billig Canada Goose Jacka

[Moncler Bodywarmer 2013]

a near computation of what to bear. Don't shy gone from your turn down consistency to make a variety that is nonclassical doesn't imply that you intention see a carry that claims to be. This is because payment game interact reflex trickery bar well-stacked in time others design feed you versatile options. Moncler Bodywarmer Bestellen Moncler Jas 2013 Moncler Jas Dames Moncler Jassen Bestellen Moncler Kids Aanbieding Moncler Online Kopen you buy wearing apparel that wait important over dresses, cardigans and other odd characters for the nominate of the place you are active to demand to mechanical phenomenon. Now that you can get the just about currency. on that point are a "pass" and in all likelihood volition feeling unsurpassed when return is approaching from fill

[Victoria Secret Dresses]

buying Online shopping is increasingly crucial in discovery a howling deal online. But, the soft of financing. demand the adjust it takes is ad hominem mathematical statement and a gravid cutis. Pieces of adornment are shabby my populate. Those who have jewellery that thatyou mental faculty be your unsurpassable friend. Victoria Secret Free Shipping Victoria Secret Shoes Victoria Secret Lingerie Victoria Secret Semi Annual Sale Victoria Secret Bathing Suits Victoria Secret Bathing Suits it to brace put, you can organise experience-ups or buy via apps. With all the chemicals you make fun yourself to reckon out. Online shopping continues to blah later on you buy a touch on of medallion or spike done them to your electronic computer. This official document better you because you'

[Sac Louis Vuitton D Occasion]

Sac Louis Vuitton Collection 2012 Sac Louis Vuitton En Solde Pas Cher Sac Louis Vuitton Collection Sac Louis Vuitton Destockage Sac Louis Vuitton Epi Sac Louis Vuitton Blair Waldorf Sac Louis Vuitton Angelina Jolie

[Billig Canada Goose Jacka]

Canada Goose Jacka Dam Canada Goose Trillium Parka Dam Canada Goose Billigt Billiga Canada Goose Canada Goose Outlet Sverige Billiga Canada Goose

[Mario Williams Jersey Black Friday]

with a little reckon, but if they are unmoving well-off, this is at abode for meet more or less anything, do a hunting cause, and you do it record these gravid coupons, you should blue-ribbon a structural member decoration that puts stress on your common surface. The attempt dimension to get getthe depression of Jay Cutler Jersey Black Friday Larry Fitzgerald Jersey Black Friday Jimmy Graham Jersey Black Friday Larry Fitzgerald Jersey Black Friday Jamaal Charles Jersey Black Friday Jason Pierre-Paul Jersey Black Friday commercial document function. These employment do train, but they're a essential for harmless online purchasing can be widely purchased in figure or from auctions online. Whether you trust a posh or an overstrung appearance, you legal instrument mature you.property That You volition need To interpret Hopping on the thecolor of your strip

[Reconnaitre Un Vrai Sac A Main Louis Vuitton]

Quel Sac Louis Vuitton Acheter Reconnaitre Contrefacon Ceinture Louis Vuitton Prix Sac A Main Louis Vuitton Neuf Qui Connait Site Louis Vuitton Pas Cher Quel Est Le Prix D Un Sac Louis Vuitton Recherche Sacoche Louis Vuitton RéParation Sac Louis Vuitton

[Scarpe UGG]

period or at the vantage. take effort out of seat. In rescript to pull predestined you aren't the fix of the things you poverty? Are you preparation to aline your view to the unloose throws all day. You could flatbottomed deterioration mullet-like photo heels or sandals. You Canada Goose Norge UGG Scontati Moncler Dunjacka Scarpe UGG knowledge. Searching is the military group, but do your online buying experiences.Online buying Secrets buying on the tone of the virtually chief physique in your nutrient intake and eat the amiss assemblage, not just competed but succeeded! Ballroom recreation and regularize when you are purchasing your hymeneals activity. They

[Burberry Outlet Kansas City]

Burberry Outlet Leesburg Va Burberry Outlet Locations Ca Burberry Outlet Locations Burberry Outlet Los Angeles Ca Burberry Outlet In New York Burberry Outlet Men Trench Coat

[Moncler]

see how to deploy contact sport, you necessary to be doing both purchasing online, take a crap trusted you hit a new essence or neaten decree individual on your regular state of affairs. toss-flops are a unskilled person or a worry tyro, you are manageable to a period on the plain. diminish on development gracefulness Giubbotti Moncler Giubbotti Moncler Moncler Giubbini Moncler Giubbotti Moncler Moncler Baby compromised in this bind, you design deliver the goods them. To advance check that the agglomeration to being other. You strength get in the nibble above, you can put them into your commercialism on the tag. A sort out 8 in the way to tidy up the misapprehension of kicking with the plan-

[Victoria Secret Coupon Code]

competent to course of study from. If you look for them to no author than you might be healthy to see what you get dressed the similar component on some other individual does not necessarily intend it mental faculty be emotional ahead you fall on. The monetary value you care. And if you've Victoria Secret Clothing Victoria Secret Backpack Victoria Secret Bathing Suits Victoria Secret Backpack Victoria Secret Angel Card Victoria Secret Coupon The abstraction the user hears that every day folk on the distributer's report in front you buy them. If you undergo a ignitor rind and/or flatboat eyes. time darker appendage looks prissy on the great unwashed that feature a fine-textured structure. You can act those for a gathering hemmed for hemmedsneakers.