Meet Thomas Schelling

THEORY
The title of this blog is the same as the title of one of the most famous books of the Cold War, Arms and Influence by Thomas Schelling. Schelling was one of the earliest theorist of nuclear deterrence (using the threat of nuclear attack to stop an actual nuclear attack) and compellence (using the threat of nuclear war to coerce an opponent into doing something). Schelling and others like Bernard Brodie and Herman Kahn helped move the discusssion in the think tanks and Washington from a combination of panic about the balance of terror with the Soviet Union to a more measured approach.

At times, the approach in places like the RAND Corporation got a bit too measured (or measurable), with complex mathematical models that attempted to model or predict how nuclear crises would play out. The problem was, the people working on these projects took the math a wee bit too seriously. Terms like "acceptable losses" and "collateral damage" implied that Strangelovean characters in the Pentagon were plotting how to "win" a nuclear exchange. Clearly, "existential deterrence" was closer to the truth: arguing that the US would "win" a nuclear war if we destroyed Moscow, Leningrad, and Minsk, while they only annihilated Chicago, was ridiculous. Deterrence worked because any attack was an unthinkable, apocalyptic event. (Much how people feel about terrorist-delivered nuclear attacks today.)

Every field has its hacks, as did the nuclear strategists. Schelling was no hack. He was a thoughtful, articulate, and often original thinker who performed some critical thought experiments about nuclear crisis management. He was also brilliant at coming up with apt analogies: for instance, he likened a nuclear confrontation to a game of chicken. Now, that statement may seem a bit trite, but Schelling's thinking went further: he identified the party with the least control over his car as the one with the most actual control over the confrontation. (One driver has more of a choice to veer off, in other words...And he feels the pressure of that choice.)

Schelling helped us "think about the unthinkable" in sober, realistic terms. His analysis veered into neither despair ("We're doomed!") nor hubris ("We have more nukes than they do--let's teach those Reds a lesson!"). Nuclear weapons had power, not so much in their use, as in the threat of their use--in some ways, almost by their existence alone. Decision makers could use the nuclear threat to engineer political outcomes, if only they (and the public) could think clearly about the subject.

Again, Clausewitz makes an appearance. I'm guessing that Schelling chose the title of his book carefully. It wasn't something obvious or meaningless, like Strategy in the Nuclear Age. The title instead implies, We have new arms in our arsenal--let's figure out how to use them as instruments of political influence.

PRACTICE
I hope that we're at the same point with terrorism that we were with nuclear weapons around 1950. A dramatic event--the first Soviet nuclear test, or later, the launching of Sputnik--makes us feel threatened in a way we never were before. Attack could come at any time, at any place. (Though, you'll certainly note, short of acquiring a nuclear weapon, the number of people a terrorist group can kill in an attack is far, far smaller than how many people could have died if one Soviet missile hit its target.) The enemy is enigmatic, relentless, and dedicated heart and soul to our destruction. Sympathizers and infiltrators may live right down the block from you, and you'd never know it.

Somehow, we managed not to lose our collective wits for too long over the Cold War nuclear threat. Fear did lead us down some dark, blind alleys, such as McCarthyism, but we undid our mistakes. Not only did the United States survive, but so did the Constitution, democracy, the rule of law, open communications and debate, a free market, and other hallmarks of "the American way of life." And the enemy finally self-destructed, in part because of the appeal of the American example to dissidents in Eastern bloc countries.

Worth remembering, I think, especially when comparing the scale of threat.

[Next time, back to the topic at hand: war aims. I realized after writing my first post, however, that I forgot to explain the blog's title.]

Comments

[samir]

I'm not so sure if exaltation of genius is necessary any longer. While it may be important to realize how the threat of nuclear weapons create and influence geopolitical strategy and action, I think it is of much greater interest to fashion an entirely different existence. The dollars and sense spent on the cold war build-up is inexcusable in a world with so much. The problem of violence and conflict is deep. It goes down to the fact that we interact so often in realtionships that are always between yourself and another. No matter what, this is how we tend to perceive and interact with the world. Instead of influence, perhaps we should think about understanding. Why do people arm themselves? Not why they are influenced to. What conditions produce arms and how can we change those conditions, so that arms aare not produced? Some Berkeley polisci profs were chatting about how Japan would be a part of China if it were not for the US. This may be true, yet we still need to do the hard work of making sure that kind of reality does not arise. Don't you think?

[JS Narins]

I must admit a relative amount of ignorance about Schelling, but I'd like to argue with you, to the ends of the Earth, about the "Chicken" analogy as an excuse for a Nixonian or Reaganesque "madman" tactic.

The party with less control of their car can not reliably veer away.

Self control is critical, or accidents will happen.

If you know precisely what you (need/want/are racing to a head on collision for) it will be crystal clear when the conditions for veering away from catastrophe have been met, and you will be able to veer.

Now, that being said, one can't be completely predictable, for a variety of reasons, and be an effective politician.

Someone did some research on schools of fish and sanity. A fish which was somewhat crazy would actually _lead_ the school. The school would turn if one of its members turns. However, if a fish was too crazy, it would turn so much that it would (in effect) leave the school behind in turns.

[I Need Money Desperately]

What conditions produce arms and how can we change those conditions, so that arms aare not produced? Some Berkeley polisci profs were chatting about how Japan would be a part of China if it were not for the US. This may be true, yet we still need to do the hard work of making sure that kind of reality does not arise. Don't you think?

[Nike SB Dunks High Tops]

If you know precisely what you (need/want/are racing to a head on collision for) it will be crystal clear when the conditions for veering away from catastrophe have been met, and you will be able to veer.

[Nike Dunk Low]

"Instead, the United States needs military professionals, with a long-term dedication to both the mission, for however long it lasts, and the service, in which they want to make their careers". .SB Dunk

We already have those. Do we need more? Absolutely. You imply that us already in the service are not professionals with long-term dedication.Cheap Nike Sb Dunks

You also imply that our troops are not creative and can't handle complex situations. You base this on what? Books? Media reports? Your time in the military (which I think is non-existent)?Custom Jordan Shoes

We know about the problems that you and other academics constantly point out way before they appear on your radar screen. We live it every day. 24/7.

"In other words, the "point of the spear" in America's wars cannot be highly-trained 24 year olds with state-of-the-art night vision and GPS gear, capable of summoning armor, air..."Air Jordan 6 Rings

When was the last time you talked to one of those 24 year olds?

I could not agree more with Neils.

What is your proposed sulution?

[ff14rmt]

rmtなどがそうだ。rmt リネージュ2これらMMORPGといわれるオンラインゲームは、リネージュ2 rmt1つのサーバーに数千人のプレイヤーが同時にログインしゲームを行なっている。ここでいうサーバーとは、物理的なサーバーではない。MMORPGでは、rmt とはサーバーやワールドと呼ばれる単位で複数の同じ世界が存在する。アトランティカ RMT3万人が同時に1つのサーバへアクセスすると処理が重くなってしまうrmt aion

[louis vuitton]

i believe that quality comes first before quantity..though it is needed to have enough numbers of words..

[Coach Outlet Online]

Appreciate the reason why your blog , the most important reason is because your blog is both fascinating and outstanding , which you can learn a lot of things , where knowledge and information is worth learning , and valuable , I do love . Thank you for your wonderful sharing .

[bedroom furniture]

great man :D

[Soundcloud Downloader]

May I simply say what a comfort to find a person that truly understands what they're discussing on the internet. You certainly realize how to bring a problem to light and make it important. A lot more people must look at this and understand this side of your story. I can't believe you are not more popular since you certainly have the gift. SoundCloud Downloader http://userscripts.org/guides/861 is the easiest way to download songs directly to your computer. You can download any song on SoundCloud. Just click and download high quality mp3 files. SoundCloud Downloader - download music from SoundCloud easily! Break limits with this awesome SoundCloud Downloader!

[minecraft download]

If you want a Premium Minecraft Account check out this generator. With it you can generate a unique Minecraft Premium Account which no one else has! You can Download the Free Premium Minecraft Account Generator http://minecraftfreakz.tk/ It's actually very difficult in this full of activity life to listen news on Television, therefore I only use internet for that purpose, and take the most up-to-date news.

[ipad 2 cases and covers]

I am now in order to be buy a house for the purpose of my mother and us a to live in”. With the free Play, a fan can practice playing our own casino games for once they want, free of pay. Another benefit is that these certificates are very sturdy. ipad 2 cases and covers aluminum iphone 5 case leather iphone case (grizzlygadgets.com) iphone cases best galaxy s3 accessories best ipad keyboard samsung galaxy s3 cases best case for iphone 5 Cases For Iphone 5 phone cases for galaxy s2 iphone cases, grizzlygadgets.com, best ipad keyboard (grizzlygadgets.com) case for samsung galaxy s2 Stylus For Ipad 3 lifeproof iphone 4s case best case for iphone 5 iphone 5 accessories ipad 3 cases phone cases for galaxy s2 iphone 5 covers phone cases for samsung galaxy s3 custom galaxy s3 case galaxy s2 phone case; grizzlygadgets.com, best iphone 4s case Ipad 2 Cases best iphone 5 accessories best case for samsung galaxy s3 iphone 4 case Best iphone cases Iphone 5 waterproof Case best ipad 4 cases galaxy s3 case s3 cases iphone 4s leather case iphone 5 cases galaxy s3 accessories Ipad 2 Case unusual iphone 4 cases best case for iphone 5 (grizzlygadgets.com) best iphone 4 case galaxy s2 accessories leather iphone case case for galaxy s3 speck iphone 4 case accessories for galaxy s3 cheap iphone cases aluminum iphone case (http://grizzlygadgets.com/) ipad mini smart cover - http://grizzlygadgets.com/ipad-mini - iphone 5 wallet case best iphone 5 case; grizzlygadgets.com, cases for the samsung galaxy s3 iphone 4 cases iphone accessories lifeproof case for galaxy s3 - grizzlygadgets.com - s3 case leather ipad 2 case [grizzlygadgets.com] mini ipad cases (grizzlygadgets.com) galaxy s3 case ipad accessories ipad accessories ipad stand waterproof iphone 4 case iphone leather case ipad mini cases iphone 4 cases iphone cases new ipad cases (Jed) iphone 4 battery Iphone 4 cases Ipad Mini Keyboard [Http://Grizzlygadgets.Com/] best iphone covers leather case for iphone 5 phone accessories ipad mini cover iphone 5 aluminum case iphone case iphone 4 Accessories ipad 2 keyboard Iphone 5 cover ipad 2 keyboard (http://grizzlygadgets.com) ipad 4 cases ipad 3 cases and covers iphone 5 aluminum case leather iphone cases unique iphone 4 case iphone aluminum case speck iphone 4 case best iphone 4 Cases cases for galaxy s3 iphone 4 leather case Best ipad Mini case (grizzlygadgets.com) samsung galaxy s2 case iphone case ipad cases with keyboard ipad 3 covers accessories for samsung galaxy s3 cases for ipad 2 ipad mini cover Ipad Keyboard Case cases for galaxy s3 iphone 5 accessories Waterproof Iphone 4 case ipad 3 cases with keyboard ipad cases iphone aluminum case speck iphone 4 case best ipad 3 cases

[ipad mini case]

For complete rules and as a consequence application visit Station Casino houses Sports Connection. The consequent advancement related to internet has also uncovered opportunities for gamers perform free games even way more. Trillion individuals have online be able to access for playing the slot machine game. ipad mini case Samsung galaxy s3 Accessories leather iphone 4 case iphone 4 case samsung galaxy s3 accessories (http://grizzlygadgets.com/accessories-for-samsung-galaxy) leather ipad 3 case ipad mini cover iphone 5 lifeproof case; http://grizzlygadgets.com, cool Iphone accessories galaxy s3 accessories best ipad mini case phone cases for samsung galaxy s3, grizzlygadgets.com, phone cases for galaxy s2 mini ipad cases ipad mini cases ipad accessories ipad 2 cases iphone case - http://grizzlygadgets.com, keyboard For ipad ipad 2 cases cheap iphone 4 cases (http://grizzlygadgets.com/iphone-case) best iphone 4s case leather iphone 5 cases speck iphone 5 case samsung galaxy s2 case iphone 4s case Best Ipad Mini Cases ipad mini covers ipad 3 cover ipad 3 cover ipad case best ipad 2 case best ipad 2 case cool iphone covers iphone 5 leather cases speck iphone 4 case - http://grizzlygadgets.com - iphone 5 leather cases samsung s3 case (http://grizzlygadgets.com) ipad 2 cases and covers (grizzlygadgets.com) case for samsung galaxy s2 phone cases for galaxy s2 cool iphone 4 case samsung galaxy s3 cases samsung galaxy S3 Case coolest iphone 5 cases best iphone 4 cases samsung galaxy s3 case iphone 4 case leather iphone 5 cases galaxy s3 waterproof case (http://Grizzlygadgets.com/) Ipad mini case targus ipad 3 case (grizzlygadgets.com) case for ipad 2 best galaxy s3 accessories iphone 5 Cases; Http://grizzlygadgets.com/iphone-Accessory, leather cases for iphone 5 [http://grizzlygadgets.com/] iphone 5 headphones iphone 4 accessories ipad mini cover (http://grizzlygadgets.com/ipad-mini) Ipad 2 Cases iphone 4s cases Ipad 3 Cases ipad charger best iphone 5 accessories (http://grizzlygadgets.com/best-iphone-cases) best iphone cases leather iphone case ipad cover (grizzlygadgets.com) iphone 5 cable cases for samsung galaxy s2 Ipad Mini Cover ipad 2 case Iphone Accessories ipad 2 cases and covers best case for samsung galaxy s3 ipad case with keyboard cases for samsung galaxy s2 cases for galaxy s2 best iphone 4s cases Ipad 3 Case Iphone 4S Cases Ipad Cover With Keyboard samsung galaxy s3 case ipad mini cases galaxy s3 waterproof case ipad keyboard (grizzlygadgets.com) Phone Cases for samsung galaxy s3 leather ipad 2 case iphone 5 best cases iphone 4S cases case for samsung galaxy s2 cases for the samsung galaxy s3 iphone 5 battery case iphone 4 cases best iphone 4 case best ipad case s3 accessories speck ipad case iphone 5 accessories iphone 4 wallet case best case for ipad 2 mini ipad case (grizzlygadgets.com) ipad mini cases best case for iphone 4s best ipad mini case waterproof iphone 4 case ipad 3 cases ipad 3 covers

[iphone 5 waterproof case]

Usually the Grail Maiden game is really unique from most any other online slots in the most important fact that there 're no pay lines. Alongside buying used games, the internet have got opportunities for subscription to assist you to game rental services simply mails. iphone 5 waterproof case cases for ipad 3 ipad 3 cases and covers Best ipad 3 Cases Ipad 2 cover best iphone case samsung galaxy s2 case ipad mini cover iphone 4 cases iphone 5 leather case (grizzlygadgets.com) s3 cases (grizzlygadgets.com) leather case for iphone 5 ipad 3 covers Ipad 2 Cases best iphone 4 case ipad 2 cases (grizzlygadgets.com) iphone 4 covers (grizzlygadgets.com) ipad covers cases for Iphone 5 (http://grizzlygadgets.Com/iphone-5-accessory) best case for galaxy S3 s3 case ipad mini keyboard case - grizzlygadgets.com - ipad accessories best iphone cases best ipad 3 case best ipad 4 cases samsung galaxy s2 case [grizzlygadgets.com] iphone 4 cases, grizzlygadgets.com, iphone 5 accessories; grizzlygadgets.com, leather ipad 2 case (http://grizzlygadgets.com) galaxy s3 accessories samsung galaxy s2 cases ipad mini cover best case for iphone 4 metal iphone 5 cases ipad 2 cases samsung galaxy s3 cases Iphone 5 charger best case for iphone 5 best iphone 5 accessories - grizzlygadgets.com, best case for samsung galaxy s3 best iphone cases s3 accessories ipad 2 covers Ipad 3 accessories iphone 4 Battery leather iphone cases cases for samsung galaxy s2 ipad mini cases ipad case (http://grizzlygadgets.com/) Leather Ipad 2 Case logitech ipad keyboard (http://grizzlygadgets.com/) zagg ipad keyboard (http://grizzlygadgets.com) ipad 4 case iphone cases ipad 3 cover ipad 2 cases best iphone accessories ipad 3 cases and covers ipad cover - grizzlygadgets.com, iphone 5 covers Ipad Mini Cover Phone Accessories iphone 5 leather case (grizzlygadgets.com) logitech ipad keyboard (http://grizzlygadgets.com) ipad 2 cases best iphone 4 cases michael kors iphone case (grizzlygadgets.com) iphone 5 chargers best ipad keyboard case - http://grizzlygadgets.com/best-ipad-case, Ipad Mini cover Iphone Case best iphone 4 cases - grizzlygadgets.com, iphone 5 cable iphone 4 cases cool iphone case best case For ipad 2 ipad mini keyboard iphone accessories (grizzlygadgets.com) cases for iphone 4 [grizzlygadgets.com] best galaxy s3 accessories custom galaxy s3 case ipad 3 keyboard iphone 4 wallet case best Iphone 5 accessories mini ipad cases Ipad 2 Cases cool ipad accessories galaxy s3 Cases samsung galaxy s3 case waterproof iphone case ipad cover with keyboard (http://grizzlygadgets.com/) waterproof ipad case kate spade ipad case best ipad mini case iphone 4 leather case ipad covers iphone 4s case (http://grizzlygadgets.com/) mini ipad covers galaxy s2 covers cases for the samsung galaxy s3 iphone 5 adapter ipad 2 case review aluminum iphone 5 cases iphone Cases, grizzlygadgets.com, cool ipad 2 cases iphone 5 headphones

[stardom the game]

The best features include ease of use, slickness, and ability to get synchronized with other Apple devices. Next thing which comes into picture is concept analysis of the custom Android games. If you're searching for an essential content with the application then your content might be blocked by such ads which really cause you to worried.

[download deer hunter game]

Games like Capture the Flag, Take over an Enemy Campsite, Tip the Barrel, or Numbers are just a few games out of many that could be played. Generally, people use it for saving him or her from water. If you are looking to cut costs, go with the steel steps.

[Www.youtube.Com]

In addition to the regular game mode, you can play in an unending mode just to see how far you can grow your empire. Youda Games is providing you the shortest and the best way to enjoy the life. In this Article we give you idea how to make a game and what is game development.

[Acheter Gemme Clash Of Clan]

impowers impregns impresas impreses imprests imprimis imprints imprison. quills quilts quince quinic quinin quinoa quinol quinsy. toolings toolless toolroom toolshed toothier toothily toothing tootlers.

[csr classics]

For instance, Seabiscuit was a popular champion race horse; however he did not succeed as a sire. 3) The Need for speed series including Shift, most wanted, and Hot Pursuit. The offer of car online games is wide, ranging from Formula 1 racing games, rally racing games, dirt bike racing games, truck racing games and many more.

[dungeon hunter 4 for android free download]

Non-player persons besides have an exhaustively described life - they besides eat, sleep, accomplish goals. Unfortunately it is unlikely there ever will be a sequel because Nintendo made the game with Square and can not make a sequel on its own without them. But Vampire the Masquerade was the game that put White Wolf on the map.

[game Of war fire age hack chips]

Graphics and detail are great, well up to the same standards the series is known for but things have not changed from the previous release. The Great War between the Northern and Southern states of the "United States" possess a peculiar interest for civil war chess set enthusiasts, not only because it was a struggle between two sections of people akin to us, but because of the epic courage with which the weaker party with ill-fed, ill-clad and ill-equipped troops, for four year sustained the contest with an opponent not only possessed of immense numerical superiority, but having the command of the sea, and being able to draw its arms and munitions of war from all manufactures of Europe. they looked impressive and had a nice, epic feel to a few of them, but on the other hand they had a tendency to grow a bit repetitive and somewhat boring in a few instances.