How great a victory?

THEORY
I'll finish this discussion about war aims with a brief note about levels or types of victory. After the Korean War, people bitterly disagreed over whether the conclusion--a return to the status quo ante--was in fact a victory. Limited war for limited objectives certainly seemed like a distastefully odd concept for a nation that had, a few years earlier, won a total victory over Germany, Italy, and Japan. Over time, however, as feelings grew less raw, and as the shape of the Cold War balance of power took a clear shape, the Korean War did in fact look more like a victory--at least, the best outcome we could have hoped for, given the circumstances. Unless we used nuclear weapons, the military stalemate would not be broken. Crossing the nuclear threshold, however, not only posed an enormous moral risk, but at the coldest practical level, could easily have shattered our alliances, created worldwide hatred of the United States, and possibly led to a nuclear confrontation with the Soviet Union. In hindsight, we can still argue how great or trivial these risks might have been, but clearly, for decision-makers at the time, they were not worth taking.

So the victory in Korea may not have been total, but it was certainly acceptable. South Korea recovered and grew prosperous. North Korea was contained.

Victory, therefore, can take three shapes:

(1) Risk elimination. Military action removes the source of the threat--the Nazi regime, the Confederacy, etc.--completely.

(2) Political success. The war ends with the political objectives achieved, without having to eradicate the enemy altogether. Most wars have ended this way, including he first Gulf War. Our success at containing Iraqi expansionism--ousting the Iraqis from Kuwait, crippling their army, and eliminating the Iraqi WMD arsenal and programs--was more than enough reason to declare victory.

(3) Revenge. This type of victory may surprise you to see in this list, but it's a legitimate measure of success. Frequently, military action doesn't need to eliminate the enemy, nor does it have to change the map of the world. Instead, it simply has to satisfy the need to hurt someone who has hurt you. I'm not arguing that this type of victory is moral, practical, or by any measure a good idea. I'm just saying that, in the real world, not the world of military theory, this is often the outcome that the people involved will say is satisfactory. (For a good discussion of the impulse for revenge as the basis of justice and one type of social cohesion, I recommend reading Emile Durkheim's The Division of Labor in Society.)

PRACTICE
Let's take both the target of our war--terrorists, terrorism, and terror--and the types of victory I sketched above and put them together:

Somewhere in this table is your definition of victory. Pick one--but choose wisely. Be prepared to ask yourself some hard questions about what the United States needs to do to win, according to your definition of victory. And be clear in your mind about what you've chosen, since as we discussed earlier, fuzzy war aims usually lead to disastrous outcomes.

Comments

[generic viagra]

So the victory in Korea may not have been total, but it was certainly acceptable. South Korea recovered and grew prosperous. North Korea was contained.

[medieval costumes]

Upon the 3 shapes you have discussed, I can only say one thing, War is no good. A NO GOOD! It only brings disaster among us all. It has no benefits. It only brings death to our innocent brothers and sister. It just satisfies the politician's need for money power.

[wench costume]

war is no good indeed.. :( Too many lives are lost.. :(

[Jordan retro 5]

Truth is better than a thousand gold pieces, a warm WanLiHan frost, Can arrive a salute sent sweet, A salute all take my thoughts, Busy day take good care of yourself all gold and silver, A LuBao from a prairie greetings, Bring me fragrant smell. From the north's blessing, Let me feel friendship is precious.

[Nike Dunk Low]

This is my first time i visit here. I discovered so numerous interesting stuff in your weblog especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all of the enjoyment here! maintain up the great work.A Ranger is one of subclasses and it is a Daeva with exceptional archery skills. Air Retro Jordan Not only can a Ranger expertly wield a bow,Buy Aion Account, Nike Sb Dunks Store
but can use a sword and dagger for close combat. SB DunkThe Ranger is also a master with various traps,Jordan Rereo 1Aion Weapon, making it both a formidable opponent on its own and a valued member of any group. Basketball Sheos Sale They have a kind of ability to manipulate traps and they are very skilled in both short and long distance attacking.

[ff14rmt]

rmtなどがそうだ。rmt リネージュ2これらMMORPGといわれるオンラインゲームは、リネージュ2 rmt1つのサーバーに数千人のプレイヤーが同時にログインしゲームを行なっている。ここでいうサーバーとは、物理的なサーバーではない。MMORPGでは、rmt とはサーバーやワールドと呼ばれる単位で複数の同じ世界が存在する。アトランティカ RMT3万人が同時に1つのサーバへアクセスすると処理が重くなってしまうrmt aion

[new jersey dui law]

Victory is making peace not war.

[Coach Outlet Online]

Victory is making peace not war.

[louis vuitton]

i believe that quality comes first before quantity..though it is needed to have enough numbers of words..

[Red Wing Boots]

let's join our hands together to stop this kind of wrong doings. It may risk lives in the future if we just let them continue.

[ray ban uk]

Quite a few couples pick out to worship both individually or they're going to obtain a diverse faith that fits them both.

[Hawkeye Avengers Costume]

thanks for this great post. i like this very much

[Latanya]

The very Grail Maiden game is probably unique from most other online slots in your current fact that there become no pay lines. It helps to make every effort possible for you to keep conduct at that level that allows all players to enjoy exhilarating proceeding of live poker. ipad 2 cover (Latanya) accessories for samsung galaxy s3 samsung galaxy s3 cases ipad case samsung galaxy s2 case iphone 5 chargers leather iphone cases [grizzlygadgets.com] ipad smart cover (grizzlygadgets.com) lifeproof case For Galaxy s3 mini ipad case Iphone 5 Cases best ipad case ipad mini covers; grizzlygadgets.com, coolest iphone 4 cases ipad covers iphone 4s case iphone 5 best cases best ipad 3 cases ipad mini case ipad mini case mini ipad covers (grizzlygadgets.com) ipad covers cheap iphone 5 cases unique iphone 4 cases ipad 2 cases best iphone accessories ipad mini cover samsung galaxy s3 accessories iphone case ipad case with keyboard (grizzlygadgets.com) ipad Keyboard ipad 4 case best iphone covers Iphone 4 Case ipad mini keyboard ipad mini case best ipad 3 cases iphone 4 cases galaxy s3 case otterbox ipad cases with keyboard accessories for galaxy s3 cool ipad 2 cases custom ipad 3 cases iphone 4 accessories (http://grizzlygadgets.com/iphone-4-4s-accessory) best ipad 4 cases ipad mini cases coolest iphone 5 cases iphone 4s leather case Best Ipad 3 Cases iphone case (http://grizzlygadgets.com) Galaxy s2 phone cases (grizzlygadgets.com) best iphone case (grizzlygadgets.com) cases for ipad 3 iphone cases ipad Case, http://grizzlygadgets.Com/ipad-Accessories, ipad 3 cases ipad mini accessories metal iphone case iphone accessories ipad mini case lifeproof iphone 5 case iphone leather case (grizzlygadgets.com) Best Ipad Case best iphone 5 Cases metal iphone 5 case ipad 3 cases cool iphone accessories iphone 4s cases phone cases for galaxy s2 ipad 3 cases best ipad keyboard cases for ipad 3 (http://grizzlygadgets.com/ipad-3-accessory) speck iphone 4 case iphone5 accessories leather iphone 5 cases s3 case life proof iphone case best iphone cases iphone case ipad bluetooth keyboard best case for iphone 4s ipad mini case cases for ipad 2 iphone accessories ipad 3 case leather iphone 5 case galaxy s2 phone case (grizzlygadgets.com) ipad cover with keyboard (Http://grizzlygadgets.com/) iphone 5 cases phone cases for samsung galaxy s2 (grizzlygadgets.com) ipad 3 cases with keyboard (grizzlygadgets.com) new ipad accessories ipad case (grizzlygadgets.com) iphone 4 case iphone 5 cable leather iphone 5 cases (grizzlygadgets.com) cheap iphone 5 cases metal iphone case ipad 3 covers Iphone 4 Case (grizzlygadgets.com) ipad mini case s3 cases coolest iphone cases (Latanya) case for samsung galaxy s2 Phone cases for samsung galaxy s3 iphone 4s case iphone5 accessories