My Photo

Core topic

« No, we're not out of ideas yet | Main | WWII: The fascist perspective »

05/12/2005

Comments

praktike

Well, let's remember what much of the Lebanese Civil War was like -- car bombs, shootings, random shellings, etc. Iraq seems quite similar if not worse than that.

Kingdaddy

Sure. I just don't think the whole idea of a threshold level for civil war is that meaningful. For one thing, I have an innate distrust of any effort to argue that what's happening in Iraq isn't a civil war. There's also no clear "tipping point" when conflict crosses the line of "Things to worry about." And finally, by the time you've explained why a particular set of events or conditions defines a civil war, you've described the things you need to worry about--those very events and conditions.

I do believe in an "etiology of internal war," to use my graduate advisor's pet phrase. I just don't think the "Is it a civil war or not?" discussion captures that etiology in any meaningful or practical way.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Tip Jar

Thanks!

Tip Jar

What I'm playing

  • Boardgames I've played recently, or I plan to play soon.